I was very interested in Obama’s speech in Cairo. My time in Beirut and with segments of the Muslim community here in Portland make this a point of keen interest. His judicious quotation of the Quran supplemented by quotations from the Talmud and the New Testament was super. In fact he quoted it four times. No president has ever made reference to the Quran before. He affirmed Muslim women who wear the hijab, but only if they make their own choice to wear it. The right balance. His thoughtful use of Arabic words, beginning with the greeting of peace from American Muslim communities, was outstanding. He even murmured “Peace be upon him” after citing Muhammad. Then he respectfully affirmed his own choice of Christianity as a young adult. Showing he could use the language and values of Arabic honoring Muslims reaches to a constituency he needs to include as president of the USA and world leader.
His comments about Palestinians were not as good. He ignored the occupation of Gaza by Egypt, which was much more harsh than that of Israel. He also ignored the reality that Palestinians in countries like Lebanon are in horrible straits. Where is the condemnation for those camps? I continue to think the Palestinians are political pawns moved by Arab countries, it seems. Similarly, affirming a two state solution ignores the reality that Fatah and Hamas fight each other to the death.
On the other hand, the president has affirmed the unbreakable tie between the USA and Israel, the reality that they must stop building settlements in the West Bank (which the last four presidents have said but not required), and that all who deny the Holocaust are baseless, ignorant, and hateful. His visit to Buchenwald with Elie Wiesel was touching as his tone became very somber, especially as he remembered his great uncle’s response to liberating a section of the camp. He also refuted the stereotypes of the USA, affirming that it is one of the greatest source of progress in the world.
Quite a speech.
One response that grabbed my attention came from Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, Iran’s supreme leader, whose criticism of the speech to a gathering to honor Ayatollah Khomeini included the statement that “People of the Middle East, the Muslim region, and North Africa — people of these regions — hate America from the bottom of their hearts.” Why did no one in the media condemn such a statement? In total contrast, President Obama committed himself to correcting misconceptions of Islam in the USA. Fortunately we can’t even imagine him, or President Bush (the reckless cowboy president by some characterizations), making such a statement about Iran.
In another incident, a convert to Islam decided to murder (commit a true hate crime) two young American soldiers at a recruiting center in Little Rock out of pure hatred for America.
It is interesting to compare President Obama’s statement on this awful incident and his statement on the assassination of Dr. George Tiller.
“I am shocked and outraged by the murder of Dr. George Tiller as he attended church services this morning. However profound our differences as Americans over difficult issues such as abortion, they cannot be resolved by heinous acts of violence.”
“I am deeply saddened by this senseless act of violence against two brave young soldiers who were doing their part to strengthen our armed forces and keep our country safe. I would like to wish Quinton Ezeagwula a speedy recovery, and to offer my condolences and prayers to William Long’s family as they mourn the loss of their son.”
He was shocked and outraged by Dr. Tiller’s assassination, but only saddened by the murderous hate crime enacted against the soldiers. The act of the first is a heinous act of violence but the second was a senseless act of violence. Why so much softer to the hate crime against totally innocent soldiers?
On the other hand, the President’s statement has very positive statements about the victims of the hate crime, but no support for Dr.Tiller, not even sympathy for his wife.
One wonders what he was signaling with that difference? But statements like this show the complexity of analyzing political speech. I find I despise the talk radio people. They just blast people whom they characterize in “us-them” terms. I refuse to listen to them. Is that sin?
Politics are so messy. Life is too, I guess. Getting things right so that misunderstandings are minimized is so difficult. Speaking clearly and with the the unction of the Spirit and the wisdom of the Church is a good start. I need all the help I can get.